June 15th 2006. ramblin' around /9: We are talking about our travels, but we're talking politics (unfortunately) >
We are talking about our travels, so I mostly listen to Gabrielle T. as she lists all the places she visited, and all the things she did managing to be a mother of three children and, as she says, a famous politician in France. "I am actually very well known in my country" she tells me, like I wouldn't believe it. "You would be surprised."
She doesn't know I can believe everything anyway, because I am always a toy in the hands of my imagination. Looking at her, it however seems possible.
We are sitting in a restaurant in Zagreb, under a pergola. From inside the restaurant comes the usual dull keyboard sound and all around us customers sit at their tables eating in silence. The risotto with mixed seafood we ordered takes us occupied for a while.
"I've been in the United States once," I say to her, trying to look interesting. "You know, for a few months, traveling around..."
"I would never go to the United States!" She says. "Never!" She stresses her point with a ironic gesture of her fist, shaken up and down.
"Yeah, my mother says the same thing. Not attracted at all. But it is a beautiful country."
"Oh, I can imagine." she says, meaning that there is no way she can be convinced to go there, and that the giving up is worthed anyway.
"You may not like many things of them, but sure they have a beautiful land," I propose. I know I am slightly annoying her with this, but I think that she can take it. "They have a beautiful language too," I add.
"I hate English language. American especially. For me it's just work."
"I like it, and I like their literature. And just think about their music. Well, you can't see everything under a political light, do you?"
"Everything is political."
Oh, how I hate that phrase. I've heard it too many times. And so we are going to talk politics. After all a part of me wants to, more than she does probably, because I need to challenge a communist whenever I find one, not that it makes me happy. I just have to.
"So do you believe in a upcoming global revolution?" I ask her.
"Yes, I do. I think it is going to happen."
"Yeah, maybe islamists will do it, 'cause they're the only ones who are opposing western nations, but not to build communism, you know? They have quite fascist states in mind."
"Communism it's an idea, it can live longer"
"The problem with communists is that they want everybody to think just like them," I'm saying at a certain point. "You know, it might be a commonplace, but there must be something into it after all. I wish communists took into consideration individual freedom more."
"Do you think that the world you live in is free?" Gabrielle T. asks. "Are the cities free or in the hands of global brands, banks and corporations? Are the people really free to travel, or just to be tourists or immigrants? Are we free to think or are we manipulated by the global media?"
"You can't use others' flaws to justify your own. Global market and capitalism are flawed, evil, but this doesn't justify the alternatives to be flawed as well, at least in theory. Otherwise I don't see what the alternative is. Just like it was no excuse to Stalin if Hitler and Mussolini also sized Poland or deported people and used a network of spies against their own citizens."
"That was not the real communism!" Gabrielle T. says. "I am not here to defend Stalin, I have a different idea of what communism must be!"
"Yet it is written that communism is a dictatorship! Either you rewrite Marx, or you change the name of your ideology, because as it is communism is meant as a dictatorship!"
We go on like this for a while, people from nearby tables turn to look at us as we raise our voices, and then the argument settles down. We haven't lost our good humor while arguing, and the evening remains pleasant, but it suddenly becomes clear that going on like this would move us away one from the other without a good reason. That's just another evidence of how much politics divide people, whereas disregard for politics does no harm.
Walking away from the restaurant and down to her place, we look at the city preparing for the night. In the main square downtown, a set of majorettes makes us smile of the sweet silliness, the useless and elegant, provincial skills of their choreography. I drop casual remarks about how all the city centers look identical because of the presence of brands all around. Gabrielle T. nods in assent, but she's obviously wondering why in the hell I am saying this now. As a matter of fact I don't know, because although I am certain of what I don't want politically or socially (almost anything) I have no idea of what I want instead, and so I can understand all positions and no position at the same time. I can challenge everyone's position and I can't propose any alternative.
Then I am into bed in a room at the end of a long corridor. A huge wardrobe makes the room smaller. Gabrielle T., on the other side of the apartment, is working on her papers for a presentation. I try to sleep without conviction. The real question is why do I get passionate about politics, communism and all that stuff? I know why. It's all personal. It's all because communism was the name behind the authority my father used against me, since when I was a little kid. That's all. This isn't something you can explain easily, but I wish I could.


